Wednesday, November 4, 2026 | 9:20 PM | Wendell A. Barwood Arena
Tuck 2, Mustangs 0 | Shots: Mustangs 20, Tuck 16
There are defensive masterpieces, goaltending duels, and the occasional tactical chess match. And then there was Wednesday night's late game, in which two winless teams combined for 36 shots, one truly regrettable goal, and enough neutral-zone hockey to qualify as a municipal traffic study.
Somebody had to win. Against all odds, it was Tuck.
After being outscored 11–2 in its first two games, Tuck beat the Mustangs 2–0 behind a 20-save shutout from emergency call-up Matthew Izard, a third-period winner by Ryan Graff, and an empty-net insurance policy courtesy of Aaron Leopold.
For the Mustangs, it was their third straight loss. For Colin "C-Money" Farr, it was another night of mostly excellent work followed by one puck he'd pay actual money to have back.
Tuck's regular goaltender was unavailable, which meant the team had to summon Izard from its so-called B team. In most beer leagues, that sentence is the beginning of a horror story. The replacement arrives wearing a borrowed jersey, asks which team he's on, and spends the first period looking for his water bottle.
Izard instead showed up and immediately began making the Mustangs question their life choices.
At 9:55 of the first, he sprawled across the crease to deny Brendan Brigham, then got a shoulder on a dangerous attempt from Logan Ritchie after Ritchie danced under a defender's stick and into the slot. At 3:40, he turned aside Van Bailey from point-blank range.
Twenty shots faced. Twenty saves. Zero goals allowed. One extraordinarily awkward Thursday morning for anyone who had been wondering whether Tuck should have called up a different goalie.
"We told him to just keep us in it," said a completely fictional Tuck spokesperson. "Apparently he interpreted that as 'do literally everything.'"
To be fair to Farr, the other end was hardly a shooting gallery. Scotty Sampson picked off a breakout pass from Lauren Williams and fired low at 8:30, but Farr was square to the shot. At 4:42, Sampson chipped the puck past a Mustangs defender, raced in, and tried to beat Farr high. Farr's shoulder had other plans.
The period ended scoreless, with Tuck holding a 7–5 shot advantage and both goalies looking suspiciously like the only adults in the building.
Ritchie took a holding penalty at 3:10 after tangling with Porter McManus, but the penalty killers survived. This was the first of several moments when the officials would remind everyone that the rulebook technically still applies after 9 PM.
The Mustangs outshot Tuck 9–2 in the second period. Nine to two. And yet the scoreboard remained as blank as a beer-league player's expression when asked to explain defensive-zone coverage.
Michael Bomes went off for tripping Patrick Daley at 12:05. Luke Kathmann followed with a tripping call against Ritchie at 9:49. With Tuck shorthanded, Bomes somehow found himself on a breakaway at 8:40 and fired the puck directly into Farr's chest, which was thoughtful of him.
With 18 seconds left, William McNabb hooked Chase Engdahl near the crease, giving the Mustangs yet another opportunity to convert a man advantage into something other than disappointment.
They didn't.
The middle period featured outside shots, missed nets, blocked lanes, and enough neutral-zone exchanges to make the Zamboni driver consider getting an early start.
The game was still scoreless when Williams was whistled for high-sticking McManus at 13:55 of the third. Off the ensuing sequence, Kathmann helped create a chance for Bomes in the slot. Farr reacted beautifully, kicking the one-timer out toward the boards.
And then, at 14:00 on the official game clock, came the moment that will haunt Farr's dreams.
The puck worked back toward the blue line, and Graff sent a rolling, tumbling, apparently harmless offering toward the Mustangs net. No thunderbolt. No screen worthy of a police report. Just a wandering biscuit with the aerodynamic ambition of a damp napkin.
It went five-hole.
Tuck 1, Mustangs 0.
Holy fuckballs.
Farr had been outstanding all night. His angles were sharp. His rebound control was largely excellent. He had made multiple high-quality stops to keep the game scoreless. And the eventual winner was a puck that looked like it had been mailed from the point using the cheapest available postage.
The official scoring credits Ryan Graff with the goal and Luke Kathmann with the assist. The rink-side account describes a longer sequence involving Bomes and a point shot. Either way, the important historical fact is that the puck crossed the line and Farr would very much like the footage destroyed.
"I tracked it the whole way," Farr did not say in an entirely fictional postgame interview. "Unfortunately, I tracked it directly between my legs."
For the record, Farr finished with 14 saves on 15 shots faced; the second Tuck goal went into an empty net. A 0.933 save percentage is normally enough to win a beer-league game. Apparently the Mustangs' offense had other plans.
At 4:54, McNabb went off for high-sticking Michael "The Trike" Cimis, giving the Mustangs another chance to tie it. The bench disputed the nature of the infraction, but the penalty was assessed, and the Mustangs still couldn't solve Izard.
That's the part that really stings. The Mustangs entered the game with seven goals in two outings. Williams, Trevor White, Will Mudge, Ritchie, and Cimis had all shown they could contribute. They had finally drawn a matchup against another winless team with a replacement goaltender.
And they got shut out.
There's a special kind of existential dread that comes from discovering your best chance to win a game was apparently last week's six-goal loss.
With Farr on the bench for the extra attacker, the Mustangs mishandled the puck at the offensive blue line. McNabb grabbed the opportunity, moved it to Aaron Leopold near center ice, and Leopold sent the puck into the abandoned net with 15 seconds remaining.
Tuck 2, Mustangs 0. Final.
The goal was technically insurance, although the Mustangs had spent the previous 44 minutes demonstrating that one goal was already a fairly extravagant amount of coverage.
First Star — Matthew Izard, Tuck: Called up from the B team, stops 20 of 20, posts a shutout, and immediately creates a goaltending controversy nobody saw coming.
Second Star — Colin "C-Money" Farr, Mustangs: Deserved better. Made the hard saves, lost on the soft one, and will now be forced to endure several weeks of jokes about five-holes and baked goods.
Third Star — Ryan Graff, Tuck: Scored the winner. It wasn't pretty, but unlike every other shot Tuck took that mattered, it went in. That's generally considered an advantage.
These are editorial selections; no official three-star list was supplied for this game.
Tuck improves to 1–2–0 and climbs to fourth place, with four goals for and 11 against. The offense remains a serious concern, but the team's first win and first shutout provide something resembling momentum. Graff now has two goals and three points through three games.
The Mustangs fall to 0–3–0, last in the five-team league, with seven goals scored and 16 allowed. Lauren Williams still leads the team with four points, while Trevor White and Will Mudge have three each. But none of that helped Wednesday, when the scoring column looked like an abandoned construction site.
The head-to-head rivalry now favors Tuck 5–4–1 across ten meetings. They may still be fourth in the standings, but at least they've found someone they can look down on.
Our pregame department predicted Mustangs 6, Tuck 4. The actual score was Tuck 2, Mustangs 0. We missed the winner, the margin, the total, and apparently the basic premise of the sport.
So congratulations to Tuck, whose solution to an 0–2 start was to call a goalie from downstairs and ask him to save the franchise. Congratulations to Izard, who did exactly that. And congratulations to Graff, whose game-winning shot will be remembered less for its velocity than for the emotional devastation it left behind.
As for the Mustangs, there's always next Wednesday.
That's not encouragement. It's a warning.
Final: Tuck 2, Mustangs 0. Two points for Tuck. Zero goals for the Mustangs. One very long night for C-Money.


