Big game in the Upper Valley, folks. The Whalers and Lumberjacks delivered the kind of “epic matchup” that can only happen at beer league pace, in front of at least five fans (six if you count the Zamboni as a sentient being).
The headline: the Lumberjacks showed up with 8 skaters — basically one line, one prayer, and one guy who was definitely asked to “just double-shift and shut up.” They took a lead, got punched in the mouth by momentum, and still clawed their way to a shootout loss… which means they walked out with a massive point that matters in the UVHL’s most prestigious race: not finishing last in a 5-team league. (Historic.)
Meanwhile the Whalers were only missing Ezra Mock… and also Kelly “The Mouth” Park — but honestly, Park being out was addition by subtraction. The Whalers played looser, faster, and with far fewer defensive lectures in the slot. That’s called growth.
This one was always going to be about the brothers: Lumberjack goalie Luke “McKickSave” McCormick versus Whalers forward “Big Game” James McCormick. And in the most predictable twist of fate imaginable, Big Game James was the victor — scoring two goals and then ending it in the shootout like he was cashing an overdue emotional check.
11:36 — LMJ 1–0
It starts with Greg “Monstah” Marsh putting a puck behind the net where Jordy “McKuckles” McGee picks it up. Whalers’ Nate “Not So Great” Robinson contributes a weak poke-check (museum-quality effort), McGee goes behind the net, and the Whalers collectively form a support group in the slot: Lochlan Park, Brandon Chiasson, and Dan Fenton all stand there watching… while Nate “Not In This Slot” DeLuca sneaks behind them for a redirect inside the far post. Great play by the Lumberjacks. Horrible defense by the Whale. (McGee to DeLuca — the “how are you STILL open?” connection.)
10:49 — WHL 1–1
The Whalers respond immediately with a “fine, we’ll try effort” sequence. Fenton starts it by regrouping to defenseman Chiasson, Chiasson hits Big Game James at the blue line, a HARD dump finds Fenton in the far corner, and Fenton throws a no-look pass to McCormick in the slot. McCormick chips it over his brother’s blocker. Great play by WHL, also… questionable LMJ coverage.
Also in the 1st: With 9:30 left, Scotty “Too Hotty” Christian takes a nap and lets DeLuca behind him. Neil “The Real Deal” MacKenzie springs him on a breakaway, but Jered “The Condor” Condon plays it perfectly and shuts the door. (The crowd of five went mild.)
4:48 — LMJ 2–1
The Lumberjacks strike again on a 2-on-1 born from two crisp breakout passes: Dayno to McGee, McGee to DeLuca with Andrew Kimbell as the decoy. DeLuca’s speed was too much for Chiasson — (who only skates hard when the puck is on his stick) — and DeLuca tucks it five-holio on Condon.
End of 1st: Whalers 1, Lumberjacks 2
Shots: Whalers 12, Lumberjacks 11
14:47 — LMJ 3–1
Thirteen seconds into the period the Lumberjacks bring down the axe. McGee gets the puck below the goal line (again), finds MacKenzie alone in the slot (again), and MacKenzie beats Condon high blocker side while four Whalers puck-watch like it’s premium streaming content.
At 12:50: If you were smart enough to bet “Nate Robinson takes a bad-angle, no-chance, hail-mary shot from the boards” at +50,000… congratulations, you’re now the league’s official finance guy. He did it. Of course he did.
11:37: Dillan Pierce takes the first penalty of the game taking down Lochlan Park (called tripping, looked more like interference). The Whalers power play lacked power, created a bad-angle look from Benjamin, and a soft “shot/pass” from Rusty Teller. They did skate around the perimeter beautifully though. 10/10 cardio.
8:31 — WHL 2–3
Big Game James strips Kimbell at the point and sends Fenton away on a 2-on-1 with McCormick joining. Fenton shoots low with purpose, a rebound explodes into the slot, and McCormick buries it. Two shots, two goals for Big Game James on his brother. Family holiday dinner status: complicated.
Nate Robinson had a point-blank backdoor chance on the same shift, but Luke McCormick comes across for the big save. (Robinson then stared into the middle distance, questioning every choice he’s ever made.)
6:09 — WHL 3–3
A full-team effort goal, meaning it was suspicious and therefore beautiful: Logan Caffrey makes a great play behind his own goal line and chips it off the glass to Cavan Benjamin. Benjy pushes to Blaine Gour, and suddenly it’s a 2-on-1 with Benjy. Gour dishes, Benjy walks down the near side and snipes top corner blocker side. Tie game. Doom for the eight-skater Lumberjacks begins to creep in.
The Whalers then take over, holding the Lumberjacks shotless for the final 6 minutes of the period. Jason Yehle takes a hooking call with 24 seconds left (only 6 shots allowed in the frame), and we head to intermission with the universe wobbling.
End of 2nd: Whalers 3, Lumberjacks 3
Shots: Whalers 16, Lumberjacks 6
Bonus misery: Ben Rouillard throws a head-fake in neutral ice, walks a defender, goes in alone… but Upper Valley lore says the kid is all Swedish and no Finnish. Save by McCormick.
If the Whalers power play in the second was bad, the Lumberjacks power play in the third was downright depressing. The Whalers PK outshoots and out-possesses LMJ, with Benjamin stripping a Lumberjack on the boards, cutting to the crease, and forcing McCormick to close the five-hole — then recover to stop Gour on the rebound. Benjy was like a dog on a bone.
Benjamin then takes a bad slashing call with 48 seconds left because, sure, why not sprinkle in a little chaos seasoning.
End of 3rd: Whalers 3, Lumberjacks 3
Shots (3rd): Whalers 5, Lumberjacks 12
1) LMJ Jake Charles vs Condon — SAVE (tried high glove, missed the net… technically the safest shot of the night)
2) WHL Fenton vs McCormick — SAVE (came up the middle, did the Mighty Ducks “pull it between the legs for show,” went backhand… easy save)
3) LMJ DeLuca vs Condon — SAVE (forehand-backhand-forehand, five-holio attempt… denied)
4) WHL Benjamin vs McCormick — “MISS” (shouldn’t have been shooting because he was in the sin bin… missed by 3’8” like his conscience guided the puck away)
5) LMJ MacKenzie vs Condon — SAVE (high glove attempt… cranked glass)
6) WHL Big Game James McCormick vs Luke McCormick — GOAL (hard low blocker side, just over the pad and under the blocker)
GAME OVER. Family group chat muted for 48 hours.
For the Whalers, it’s another win and more evidence they’re one of the league’s actual adult teams. Condon was steady, the forecheck finally woke up, and Big Game James delivered the kind of performance that makes you walk around the rink like you own the place.
For the Lumberjacks, this was a “loss” that felt like a win. Eight skaters, heavy minutes, a 3–1 lead, and they still forced it to a shootout. That loser point matters — because in the UVHL, survival isn’t about glory. It’s about not being the one team sitting at home in March, watching playoff hockey like a sad Victorian ghost.


